Pelican Bay

Pelican Bay is a large master-planned beachfront community in North Naples, with condominiums, villas and single-family homes and a shared beachfront reached through community facilities. Bay Colony is a gated enclave at its northern end. Buyers comparing the two are usually weighing Bay Colony’s second gate, private beach club and Gulf-front towers against Pelican Bay’s broader range of product, price points and neighborhoods.

How to compare

• Beach access: Bay Colony’s beachfront towers front the Gulf directly; most of Pelican Bay reaches the beach through community facilities.
• Price per square foot: Gulf-front Bay Colony towers generally command a premium; validated building-level figures are published on this site as they are confirmed.
• Product mix: Pelican Bay offers more variety, including low-rise and single-family; Bay Colony is concentrated in high-rise towers plus a few villa and estate neighborhoods.
• Governance: each condominium has its own association, budget and reserves in addition to community-level obligations; read both layers.

A recent Pelican Bay benchmark

In June 2026 a penthouse at Mystique in Pelican Bay closed at about $3,182 per square foot, reported as a Naples condominium resale record. It is a ceiling, not a typical sale, but it frames how far the top of the Pelican Bay market has moved.

Pelican Bay-wide market data will be added to this site as it is validated. See the current market report ›