Independent market intelligence for Bay Colony’s beachfront towers, Pelican Bay residences, current availability, and long-term sales trends.
Operated by Galen Gonzalez, REALTOR®, 239 Florida at Premiere Plus Realty · Not affiliated with any association, developer or sales office
Bay Colony is a private, gated enclave within Pelican Bay in North Naples. This site is an independent guide to its buildings and market, not an official community resource.
Bay Colony sits at the northern end of Pelican Bay, behind its own gate, with a line of Gulf-front high-rise towers along Bay Colony Drive, a second row of high-rises on the Upper Clam Bay and preserve side of the road, a single mid-rise, and four low-rise neighborhoods of villas and single-family homes. Residents have access to the private Bay Colony Beach Club and, as part of Pelican Bay, to Pelican Bay’s beachfront amenities and community facilities. Membership structures and fees vary by neighborhood and should be confirmed in the association documents for any specific residence.
Building by building, Bay Colony is not one market. The six beachfront towers, the four bay-side towers and the low-rise neighborhoods differ in age, floor plate, view orientation, unit count and price per square foot — which is why this site organizes the community by building rather than treating it as a single average.
Compare towers on age, size and validated market indicators, open a building page for its history and positioning, then request current availability or a private consultation. Every figure carries an “as of” date and links to the methodology.
Browse all buildings ›Verified facts for each building and neighborhood. Market indicators appear only once validated against permitted MLS data.
22-story beachfront tower delivered in 1997 by WCI Communities, three buildings south of the Ritz-Carlton; common areas remodeled in 2016.
$1,693/SF median, trailing 24 mo · $5.51M avg sale · data through October 1, 2026
2,860–3,325 sq ft typical; penthouses to 7,000+ sq ft
View The Biltmore Market Report ›21-story beachfront tower delivered in 1998 by WCI with only 31 residences — the fewest of any Bay Colony beachfront tower.
$1,643/SF median, trailing 24 mo · $11.38M avg sale · data through October 1, 2026
approx. 6,085–8,550 sq ft; upper penthouses 10,000+ sq ft (reported)
Explore The Windsor ›22-story, 75-residence beachfront tower delivered in 1996 by WCI, sited between the Bay Colony Beach Club, the tennis courts and the Ritz-Carlton, with a private walkway to the hotel.
$2,021/SF† median, trailing 24 mo (3 sales) · $7.20M avg sale · data through October 1, 2026
2,870–3,410 sq ft typical; penthouses to ~6,950 sq ft
Explore Remington ›22-story, 75-residence WCI beachfront tower completed in 1994, with four floor plans and a dune walkover to the beach.
$1,775/SF† median, trailing 24 mo (4 sales) · $6.71M avg sale · data through October 1, 2026
2,750–3,450 sq ft typical; penthouses 6,000–7,000+ sq ft
Explore Brighton ›Second beachfront tower built in Bay Colony (delivered 1992 by WCI): 20 stories, 75 residences, four units per floor with wrap-around terraces.
$1,605/SF median, trailing 24 mo · $5.47M avg sale · data through October 1, 2026
2,635–3,274 sq ft typical; two penthouses ~5,646 sq ft
Explore The Carlysle ›The first high-rise built on the beach in Bay Colony (completed 1991, WCI) and the southernmost beachfront tower; the only Bay Colony high-rise with its own private tennis facility.
$1,331/SF median, trailing 24 mo · $3.65M avg sale · data through October 1, 2026
2,125–3,027 sq ft typical; penthouses ~5,000 sq ft
Explore Contessa ›The newest and largest Bay Colony high-rise, developed by WCI in 2002 with about 106 residences on the Upper Clam Bay side of Bay Colony Drive; common areas renovated in early 2024.
$1,526/SF† median, trailing 24 mo (4 sales) · $6.08M avg sale · data through October 1, 2026
approx. 3,815–4,860 sq ft
Explore Trieste ›69-residence WCI tower built in 2000 — the westernmost of the three bay-side towers and the closest of them to the beach; two-story penthouses with 20-foot ceilings.
$1,077/SF median, trailing 24 mo · $3.05M avg sale · data through October 1, 2026
2,600–2,900 sq ft typical; penthouses 5,000–5,200+ sq ft
Explore Salerno ›19-story, 65-residence WCI tower completed in 1999 on the Upper Clam Bay side of Bay Colony Drive, with private elevators opening directly into residences.
$1,282/SF median, trailing 24 mo · $3.12M avg sale · data through October 1, 2026
2,520–2,800 sq ft typical; penthouses ~5,000 sq ft
Explore Toscana ›The first off-beach high-rise in Bay Colony (1994): a 15-floor, 39-residence tower with three residences per floor at the edge of a native bird rookery.
$1,147/SF median, trailing 24 mo · $2.95M avg sale · data through October 1, 2026
2,005–2,610 sq ft typical; penthouses ~3,693 sq ft
Explore Marquesa ›Bay Colony's only mid-rise condominium: a 7-story, 26-residence open-air atrium building completed in 1996, adjacent to Villa La Palma.
$902/SF† median, trailing 24 mo (2 sales) · $2.31M avg sale · data through October 1, 2026
approx. 2,110–2,560 sq ft
Explore Mansion La Palma ›The only beachfront single-family enclave in Bay Colony: 12 custom Gulf-front homes behind a second security gate, built individually between 1991 and 2002, several since rebuilt.
$1,530/SF† median, trailing 24 mo (2 sales) · $16.75M avg sale · data through October 1, 2026
approx. 3,700 to 15,000+ sq ft (brokerage-reported; varies widely)
Explore The Strand ›A 58-home village of Mediterranean-style detached and attached villas with exterior maintenance included, built 1991–1995, mostly on lake or preserve lots near the front of Bay Colony.
$1,391/SF† median, trailing 24 mo (4 sales) · $4.75M avg sale · data through October 1, 2026
approx. 2,600–6,000 sq ft
Explore Vizcaya ›Bay Colony's inland single-family neighborhood inside the main gate: 66 custom homesites, directly east of Trieste, with lake, landscaped or Hardwood Hammock Preserve views. First homes completed in 1990; a number have since been rebuilt.
$1,172/SF median, trailing 24 mo · $8.66M avg sale · data through October 1, 2026
approx. 3,080 to 10,000+ sq ft (brokerage-reported)
Explore Bay Colony Shores ›A gated enclave of 22 detached villas built 1996–1998 on cobblestone streets off La Palma Lane, each with a water view and two- to three-car garage; single- and two-story plans with exterior maintenance included.
$1,263/SF median, trailing 24 mo · $4.17M avg sale · data through October 1, 2026
approx. 2,840–3,850 sq ft living area (MLS); 3,600–4,600 sq ft total (brokerage-reported)
Explore Villa La Palma ›Not inside the Bay Colony gate: a separately gated community of 75 estate homes on two-thirds- to one-acre homesites within Pelican Marsh, around the Bay Colony Golf Club. Brokerage sources report Bay Colony Beach Club membership for homeowners; golf membership is separate.
$975/SF† median, trailing 24 mo (4 sales) · $7.97M avg sale · data through October 1, 2026
4,000 sq ft minimum; most approx. 5,200–11,000 sq ft (MLS)
Explore The Estates at Bay Colony Golf Club ›Building facts are reported by brokerage and association sources (cited on each building page); year-built figures are reported, not appraiser-verified. Methodology and limitations.
Only validated, dated metrics are displayed.
Bay Colony condominiums, all 11 buildings · 67 closed sales in 24 months · 1 pending · data through October 1, 2026 · villa and home neighborhoods reported separately · Methodology
Naples luxury market context (not Bay Colony-specific) · trailing twelve months · as of September 2026 · Source: Naples Area Board of REALTORS® (NABOR) monthly market report · Methodology
Sortable table and clickable chart. Select any row or bar for that building.
| Tower | Year built | Residences | Typical living area | Active listings | Median $/SF (24 mo) | Avg sale price | 12-mo sales | Months of supply | Report |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The BiltmoreGulf-front tower | 1997 | 75 | 2,860–3,325 sq ft typical; penthouses to 7,000+ sq ft | 2 | $1,693/SF | $5.51M | 6 | 4.0 mo | View report › |
| The WindsorGulf-front tower | 1998 | 31 | approx. 6,085–8,550 sq ft; upper penthouses 10,000+ sq ft (reported) | 1 | $1,643/SF | $11.38M | 0 | no sales | View report › |
| RemingtonGulf-front tower | 1996 | 75 | 2,870–3,410 sq ft typical; penthouses to ~6,950 sq ft | 2 | $2,021/SF† | $7.20M | 3 | 8.0 mo | View report › |
| BrightonGulf-front tower | 1994 | 75 | 2,750–3,450 sq ft typical; penthouses 6,000–7,000+ sq ft | 0 | $1,775/SF† | $6.71M | 3 | none listed | View report › |
| The CarlysleGulf-front tower | 1992 | 75 | 2,635–3,274 sq ft typical; two penthouses ~5,646 sq ft | 0 | $1,605/SF | $5.47M | 4 | none listed | View report › |
| ContessaGulf-front tower | 1991 | 76 | 2,125–3,027 sq ft typical; penthouses ~5,000 sq ft | 1 | $1,331/SF | $3.65M | 8 | 1.5 mo | View report › |
| TriesteBay-side high-rise | 2002 | 106 | approx. 3,815–4,860 sq ft | 2 | $1,526/SF† | $6.08M | 1 | 24.0 mo | View report › |
| SalernoBay-side high-rise | 2000 | 69 | 2,600–2,900 sq ft typical; penthouses 5,000–5,200+ sq ft | 0 | $1,077/SF | $3.05M | 5 | none listed | View report › |
| ToscanaBay-side high-rise | 1999 | 65 | 2,520–2,800 sq ft typical; penthouses ~5,000 sq ft | 0 | $1,282/SF | $3.12M | 3 | none listed | View report › |
| MarquesaBay-side high-rise | 1994 | 39 | 2,005–2,610 sq ft typical; penthouses ~3,693 sq ft | 3 | $1,147/SF | $2.95M | 0 | no sales | View report › |
| Mansion La PalmaMid-rise condominium | 1996 | 26 | approx. 2,110–2,560 sq ft | 0 | $902/SF† | $2.31M | 1 | none listed | View report › |
Select a column heading to sort. Validated data through October 1, 2026. Market indicators, not appraisals. † Fewer than five closed sales in the 24-month window; one sale can move the median. Read it as a reference point. · Methodology
Bay Colony condominium buildings · data through October 1, 2026 · select a row for the building
Remington$2,021† per square foot, data through October 1, 2026Brighton$1,775† per square foot, data through October 1, 2026The Biltmore$1,693 per square foot, data through October 1, 2026The Windsor$1,643 per square foot, data through October 1, 2026The Carlysle$1,605 per square foot, data through October 1, 2026Trieste$1,526† per square foot, data through October 1, 2026Contessa$1,331 per square foot, data through October 1, 2026Toscana$1,282 per square foot, data through October 1, 2026Marquesa$1,147 per square foot, data through October 1, 2026Salerno$1,077 per square foot, data through October 1, 2026Mansion La Palma$902† per square foot, data through October 1, 2026A market indicator, not an appraisal. † Fewer than five closed sales in the 24-month window; one sale can move the median. Read it as a reference point. How this is calculated.
Explore The Biltmore’s long-term price-per-square-foot trend, recent sales, floor premium, supply, and current market context — built from 106 recorded closings since 1997.
Data through October 1, 2026 · Methodology
A high-level comparison of the Bay Colony gated tower lifestyle against the alternatives buyers usually weigh. Deeper guides will follow.
Pelican Bay offers a wide range of condominiums and single-family homes with shared beachfront amenities; Bay Colony adds a second gate, its own beach club and a concentrated set of Gulf-front towers. Buyers typically trade a higher per-square-foot entry for privacy and beachfront immediacy.
Old Naples offers walkability to Third Street and the beach blocks, with more low-rise and single-family product; Bay Colony offers direct Gulf frontage, elevated views and full-service building operations. The deciding question is daily beach access versus a walkable town.
New downtown residences such as The Avenue (about $1,950/SF asking, computed) put owners steps from Fifth Avenue South in low-rise buildings. Bay Colony trades that street life for Gulf frontage, height and a gated setting.
Port Royal is primarily single-family estate property with private waterfront and a different ownership profile. Bay Colony towers suit owners who want lock-and-leave convenience with beachfront views rather than a private-estate footprint.
The Four Seasons Private Residences at the former Naples Beach Club add a branded, resort-serviced beachfront option; its first reported beach-house closing (May 2026) worked out to about $2,222/SF. The Biltmore’s trailing 24-month median is $1,693/SF, with a 29-year sale history.
New Naples beachfront construction is asking well above $3,000/SF at the top of the market, in exchange for new systems and contemporary plans. Established towers offer a long closed-sale history and immediate occupancy. Galen’s new-construction research covers the pipeline.
Galen Gonzalez provides data-driven buyer and seller representation across Bay Colony, Pelican Bay, and Naples beachfront condominiums. His research combines building-level sales history, current market conditions, and residence-specific positioning.
Buyer representation, seller pricing and residence-specific analysis across Bay Colony and Pelican Bay.
You receive current availability, recent sales, the tower comparison, long-term price trends, and residence-specific market context.
Request the Bay Colony & Pelican Bay Market Report. Tell me whether you are buying, selling or an owner, and I will send the report with context for your situation.
Your request is in — Galen will follow up directly.
